Wedding tasting checklist: 12 caterer questions

Your tasting is one of the most important meetings in your wedding planning process. These 12 questions help you evaluate food, logistics, and your caterer.

Why your wedding tasting matters more than you think

Most couples treat the tasting like a fun date night. Try some food, say "that's good," sign the contract. But the tasting is actually one of the most consequential meetings in your entire wedding planning process. It's where you test compatibility with your caterer, fine-tune a menu that 150 people will eat, and decide whether this team can execute on the biggest day of your life.

Go in prepared and you'll leave with a menu you're genuinely excited about. Go in without a plan and you'll nod along, forget half of what you tried, and second-guess your choices for weeks.

These 12 questions will help you use the tasting to get real answers, not just a nice meal. They're organized by category so you can work through them naturally during the appointment. If you want the full picture on wedding catering menu planning in Atlanta, that pillar guide covers everything from first consultation to day-of execution.

Couple at wedding tasting session with plated dishes in Atlanta

What to bring to your tasting

Show up ready to work, not just eat. Bring:

Questions about the food

1. Can you adjust the seasoning or preparation of any dish we try today?

The tasting should be a starting point, not a final answer. A caterer who takes notes and says "I can pull back the heat on that" or "let me try a different sauce" is showing you how they'll collaborate throughout the planning process. If the answer is "the menu is set as-is," that tells you something about flexibility.

2. Which dishes on this menu are the strongest sellers at weddings your size?

This question gets you practical intelligence. A dish might taste great at a table for four but fall apart when it's plated for 200. Your caterer knows which items hold temperature, transport well, and consistently get positive responses at scale.

3. How do you handle dishes that need to accommodate multiple dietary restrictions?

Weddings in Decatur, Buckhead, and across the Atlanta metro routinely have guests with gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan, nut-free, and kosher needs at the same table. Ask how the caterer builds accommodations into the main menu rather than creating separate meals that single people out. The dietary needs menu planning guide goes deeper on this topic.

4. What's seasonal right now, and how would the menu change if our wedding is in a different season?

This reveals whether your caterer thinks about ingredients seasonally or just runs the same menu year-round. A chef who adjusts based on what's available locally will deliver better flavor and better value. It also gives you a preview of how adaptable they are.

Close-up of wedding tasting plates with miniature entree portions

Questions about logistics and execution

5. How do you handle the timing between courses when there are toasts, dances, or other interruptions?

This is where wedding catering experience shows. A caterer who works weddings regularly has a system for holding food at the right temperature during a 15-minute toast session and then resuming service without a quality drop. If they look confused by the question, they haven't done enough weddings.

6. What does your day-of staffing look like for our guest count?

Get a specific number. How many servers? Is there a lead captain? Who manages the kitchen? Who coordinates with the DJ and planner? A caterer who can't give you a clear staffing breakdown hasn't fully planned your event yet.

7. Have you worked at our venue before, and what should we know about the kitchen setup there?

Venue familiarity is a real advantage. A caterer who has worked your Sandy Springs or Midtown venue before knows the kitchen limitations, the load-in process, and the timing quirks. If they haven't, ask how they plan to handle the site visit and preparation.

8. What happens if our guest count changes significantly after we finalize the menu?

Guest counts shift. It's inevitable. Ask about the adjustment deadline, how a headcount increase affects pricing, and whether there's a minimum guarantee. Knowing the rules now prevents surprises later. The wedding catering cost breakdown covers how headcount changes affect the bottom line.

Questions about the relationship

9. Who is our primary point of contact between now and the wedding day?

You want one person who knows your event inside and out. If the person running the tasting isn't the person managing your wedding day, ask how the handoff works and when you'll meet the day-of lead.

10. How many planning check-ins should we expect between now and the event?

Professional caterers have a planning cadence: post-tasting follow-up, mid-process check-in, final details meeting, and a week-before confirmation call. If a caterer goes quiet after the deposit, that silence will continue on event day.

11. Can you share references from couples who had a similar wedding size and style?

Reviews online are helpful but curated. Ask for direct references you can actually contact. A caterer confident in their work will hand these over without hesitation. A couple who had 175 guests at a Roswell estate will give you different feedback than one who had 40 at a Marietta restaurant.

12. What's included in our contract, and what would be billed as an add-on?

Tastings feel warm and collaborative. Contracts are where the details live. Ask about setup and breakdown fees, overtime charges, cake-cutting fees, and any other line items that might appear after you've already signed. Get the full picture before you commit.

"At our tasting they thoughtfully listened to our feedback and answered our questions in order to make our event unique, special and a success. They also curated the menu based off our likes/dislikes and then made adjustments as needed to ensure we had the perfect meal!" - Brittany L.

Chef preparing tasting portion with garnish for wedding menu planning

What this means for your event

  • Treat the tasting like a working session, not just a meal. Bring notes and a checklist.
  • Pay attention to how the caterer responds to feedback. That responsiveness will carry through to your wedding day.
  • Use the tasting to narrow your menu, not just to eat. Come ready to make decisions.

For a complete walkthrough of every step in the wedding catering process, from initial consultation through day-of execution, read our ultimate guide to wedding catering in Atlanta.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a typical wedding tasting last?

Plan for 90 minutes to two hours. That gives you time to try each dish, ask questions, discuss options with your partner, and go over logistics. Rushing through a tasting defeats the purpose.

Should we bring our wedding planner to the tasting?

If you have one, yes. Your planner can ask logistical questions you might not think of and will help coordinate between the caterer and other vendors later. If you don't have a planner, bring someone organized who can take notes while you focus on the food.

Is it okay to ask for a second tasting if we're not sure?

Most caterers are open to a follow-up tasting, especially if you have specific adjustments you want to try. Ask about it directly. A caterer who wants your business will work with you to get the menu right rather than pressuring you to commit on the first round.

Book your tasting

At Exquisite Delites, the tasting is a collaboration. Chef Eric and Sandra sit down with you, listen to your vision, and build the menu around your preferences, your guest list, and your wedding day. Get in touch to schedule yours.

What Our Clients Say

★★★★★ 5.0 on Google

We used them for my sister's wedding last month and I'm so happy we did. The Chef and his wife (Sandy) are the utmost professional and kind. At our tasting they thoughtfully listened to our feedback and answered our questions in order to make our event unique, special and a success. They also curated the menu based off our likes/dislikes and then made adjustments as needed to ensure we had the perfect meal! Often times I've found that catering companies do not always deliver the same caliber of food when making food for larger groups and or weddings; However That's Definitely Not the case with Exquisite Delites, the nailed it from start to finish!!! The setup on the day of the wedding was beautiful and the food was even better than it was at our tasting 10/10! We got so many compliments on the food! I highly recommend Exquisite Delites for any special event in Atlanta (or wherever they serve). We will definitely be using them in the future. Also I want to point out - Sadia was an excellent server, and I love how this is a family owned business yet they nail it when it comes to customer service!

Brittany L.
Google Review
★★★★★ 5.0 on Google

I wanted to express our appreciation for a job well done! Yesterday was nothing short of amazing. The care shown by you, Chef and your servers was phenomenal. My siblings and I were pleased beyond measure. The food was absolutely delicious. The salmon and the chicken were cooked to perfection. The potatoes were a smash... no pun intended. The green beans were tasty. The salad was really good and the charcuterie board was a nice touch. Chef's addition of various textures was masterful. The food was outstanding to say the very least. As if the flavorful food wasn't enough, the presentation took the event over the top! The buffet table looked fabulous. It was really eye pleasing. A fantastic job all around!!! Thank you for creating a culinary masterpiece. Just as your company name suggests, we truly loved and experienced your "Exquisite Delites."

RXJ
Google Review
★★★★★ 5.0 on Google

Chef Eric and Sandra Centeno's incredibly well-seasoned and delicious food, gorgeous presentations, detailed preparation, and collaborative teamwork make them the ideal catering partner. You just set the vision and wait for the magic!

Marjorie M.
Google Review

Other blogs